What Questions Should You Ask on a Real Estate Lead Call?

By William Mansour

Real estate agent on a phone call at her desk

Most lead calls go sideways in the first minute, because the agent starts selling before they know one real thing about the person on the other end.

The short answer: ask questions in three levels. Start with surface questions that open the door, move to problem questions that uncover the real reason they want a change, then ask consequence questions that help them do their own math on staying versus moving. Listen about 70% of the time and talk about 30%. Never ask their budget straight out. And end every call with a specific day and time to follow up.

That's what we worked through in this week's Lead Call Mastery session, Book 3: Question Based Selling. Here's the framework, the way I teach it.

Get beside the client, not across from them

When you lead with statements, you sound like a salesperson. Statements come across as aggressive. Questions come across as curious. The goal is to sit beside the client and figure things out together, not sit across the table and push.

That starts in the first 15 seconds. Keep it light and human. Sound like a busy professional who's glad they reached out, not someone reading a script.

Level 1: Surface questions

Surface questions open the door without tripping the alarm. This is not the time for timelines, mortgages or "what's your budget."

Try questions like:

  • What got you interested in this area?
  • How long have you lived where you are now?
  • Does commuting matter for you?
  • Are there kids in the picture?

Notice what's missing: beds, baths and budget. I call those the three Bs, and they can wait. Ask a few questions that have nothing to do with real estate on the surface. Once you know their situation, you can go further into schools, parks and sports.

If someone opens with "I'm just looking," don't fight it. Ask what types of homes they've been looking at, then ease into your surface questions.

Level 2: Problem questions

Now you're looking for the real reason they're thinking about a move. It's usually one of four things: logistical, situational, emotional or financial.

Stay curious, not scripted:

  • What's the main thing that has you thinking about a change right now?
  • Where do you picture yourself a year from now?
  • What's different about where you are now compared to what you want?

The person who feels heard is the person who calls you back.

Level 3: Consequence questions

Consequence questions help the client work out the cost of staying versus moving, in their own words. That might be what they're spending on rent, or a worry about losing money if the market dips.

You're not telling them what it costs. You're asking questions so they do the math themselves. That lands a lot harder than anything you could say.

Don't ask the budget directly

Asking "what's your budget?" puts people on guard. Do your homework instead. If the lead came from your own website, look at the homes they viewed, and run a market report for the area so you can share typical prices. Then let them tell you what they're approved for. Most people will volunteer it once you've shown them you know the market.

Use silence on purpose

After a big question, wait three to five seconds. It feels long. People don't like the pause, so they keep talking, and that's usually when you hear the real answer.

Practise that pause in everyday conversations too. It gets easier.

Mirror, reflect and write it down

Match the lead's tone and energy. Then repeat back what you heard so they know you're listening. And take notes. A call with no notes is a call you'll forget, and the lead will notice.

Before you hang up, summarize the whole call: what they want, and the real reason they called.

Close with a specific next step

Don't say "call me whenever it's convenient." That closes the door. Book a specific day and time, like Tuesday at 11. Set up or adjust their search alert. Then update your CRM right away, follow up on the day you set, and keep adding value with search alerts, plans and newsletters.

If they don't pick up: after two missed calls, send a short video message within about five minutes. Introduce yourself, say you're busy right now, and let them know you'll call back.

If they only left an email: email them and ask for a quick phone call. If you've already emailed once, wait until the next day to follow up rather than sending another one the same afternoon.

A 10-minute post-call check

After each call, take ten minutes or less and ask yourself:

  1. Did I ask more than I told?
  2. Did I let silence sit after my biggest question?
  3. Did the lead talk more than I did?
  4. Did I reflect back and summarize?
  5. Is there a follow-up date in the CRM?
  6. What personal detail did I write down?
  7. What's one statement I'll turn into a question next time?

Practise before the next real call

You don't have to practise on live leads. Use an AI role-play bot. Have it play the lead while you work through all three question levels. Or ask it to list the ten questions agents ask most, then turn each statement you normally make into three questions. Do a few reps and you'll hear the difference on your next call.

FAQ

What are the three levels of questions on a real estate lead call?

Surface questions open the conversation, problem questions uncover the real reason for a move, and consequence questions help the client weigh the cost of staying versus moving.

How much should I talk on a lead call?

Aim for about 30% talking and 70% listening. If you're doing most of the talking, you're pitching, not discovering.

Should I ask a buyer what their budget is?

Not directly. Look at what they've viewed, share typical prices from a market report, and let them tell you what they're approved for.

How long should I pause after asking a question?

Three to five seconds. Most people will fill the silence, and that's often when you get the real answer.

What's the best way to end a lead call?

Summarize what they want and why they called, then book a specific day and time to follow up, and update your CRM right away.

Join The Call

If you want to practise this live with other agents, come to Lead Call Mastery. It's every Monday at 11 AM ET on Zoom, alongside AI Advantage on Tuesdays and Niche Ninjas on Wednesdays. The live trainings are free, and you can just come and listen. No pitch, no pressure.

Join The Call, see the schedule and this week's topics at theagentsadvantage.ca/calendar.

William Mansour, The Agents Advantage